The Wrong Board

A colleague who has spent her career at large, well-resourced nonprofits was complaining

Your board, perhaps?

about a recent event she attended.  The purpose of the event was to match potential board members with nonprofits needing new board members.  The problem according to my colleague?  The potential board members were all inappropriate—too young, too unconnected, too little financial heft.

But aren’t these often the problem with board members of most of our nonprofits?  Individuals who can afford to serve on the board of a major university, hospital, large national nonprofit are mainly not interested in working with a nonprofit where the operating budget is less than the board gives at those larger organizations.  And so, what you get, are those who care—sometimes passionately—about your work but may not be sufficiently affluent or influential to move your organization’s needle much.

Does this make them inappropriate?  Not necessarily.  But it may make them very frustrating.

We have all come to believe our board members should be our main fundraisers.  And if your board is not well connected; doesn’t have a lot to give; has no experience in philanthropy nor friends who have such experienced, they will not effective fundraisers.  Unless, of course, you take the time to teach them not just what to do but also how to do it.

That means working with them—and that means taking the time to get to really know them.

How?  The same way you get to know anyone.  You spend time with them.

I strongly urge my clients to meet one-on-one with every single board member to discuss board roles and responsibilities at least two times a year.  Yes, it can be time consuming, but it is also well worth the time.

At those meetings, ask them open-ended questions and give them space to answer.  Then probe more deeply. At your very first meeting, ask “tell me why you agreed to serve on our board.”

Often, when I asked my board member that question, the answer was a shrug and then something to the effect of, “Well, Joe asked me.”

Keep smiling.  “Many people come on our board because of a personal relationship with another board member.  What I really want to know is what is it about our organization that keeps you on the board.  What do we do that really matters to you?”

It would be lovely if that opened a floodgate of words.  But often it does not. Or the floodgate it does open is not the one you wanted.  In either case, your job is to facilitate the conversation.  Sometimes that means nudging the person to focus in a different direction.

“Yes, I agree. We could do things better (or there are some interesting people on our board or that sounds like an interesting—note that word, it is so good and non-judgmental– program).  And I would love your input.  But first, I really want to understand what keeps you at the table.”

As you get to know your board members, you may discover that they are better connected than either of you imagined, or are more creative, helpful, willing than you every hoped.  And as you truly engage them with interesting projects and offer important topics for the board to discuss (and imagine, a board meeting where the members are passionate, engaged, involved!), you may well discover that rather than the wrong board you actually have a board that is totally and completely right for you.



Janet Levine works with nonprofits, helping to train boards to be the right board.  Learn more at  Sign up for the newsletter and do contact Janet for a free, 30 minute consultation.


About janetlevineconsulting

For over 20 years, Janet Levine has worked for and with nonprofit and educational organizations, helping to grow their advancement programs. Her consulting company, Janet Levine Consulting, serves a wide range of organizations from small, all-volunteer agencies to major national organizations. She regularly teaches courses in non-profit management, fundraising and grant development, both face-to-face and online at In addition to her nonprofit work, Janet brings years of experience as a business and sales manager in the for-profit sector. She has an MBA from the Graziadio School of Business at Pepperdine University.
This entry was posted in boards and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s